
As many of you know, Pappy Van Winkle is highly sought after, hard to find, and considered to be the best bourbon in the world. I have been blessed with the opportunity to experience four different Pappy Van Winkle offerings; the 10 year, 15 year, 20 year, and 23 year. These bourbons have served as my benchmark against which all other bourbons are compared.
Of the four, the 15 year is actually my favorite. It is sublime and the second best (not the best) bourbon I have ever had (my favorite is not a Pappy and will be the subject of a future review). The 15 smells how I imagine heaven might smell. It smells of toffee, vanilla, and oak. The taste, however, is what will take your breath away. It starts out silky and then explodes into flavors of vanilla and caramel. It has a long finish that tastes sweet but yet isn’t and it is tempered by just a perfect amount of burn. You want the flavor to stay in mouth forever. I rate the 15 year as a 97.
The rest of the Pappys in order of age:
10 year- nose is nice, not as potent as the 15 year. The flavor is smooth and not as full bodied as the 15 year – it is reminiscent of Eagle Rare 10 year bourbon, with hints of leather and toffee. The finish is very smooth with really minimal burn. I rate the 10 year as a 92.
20 year – nose is much like the 15 year and the flavor is much the same as the 15 year, but obviously aged longer and has taken on more of the flavor from the charred oak barrel, giving this bourbon a smoky edge not found in the 15 year. Overall a great bourbon, which I rate at 94.
23 year – considered to be the Holy Grail of bourbons. The bourbon has a huge nose and flavor. The nose is caramelly but also very earthy, almost smelling of dirt or minerals. The flavor starts timid but grows in strength. It erupts into an explosion of caramel, oak, leather, and has a minerally bite (any earthy – primal experience). It definitely lives up to the hype. I rate this at 95.
Bob